PMI Crest
PMI
4 February 2019

Pensions Aspects February 2019

Time for the emperor to get new clothes. Read the latest issue on a look at the upcoming trends in communication.

Going Dutch: what’s the appeal of CDC?

After much industry discussion, the appearance towards the end of October of a DWP consultation demonstrated that the Government is serious about the introduction of Dutch-style Collective Defined Contribution (CDC) schemes. Political messages have, up to this point, been somewhat mixed. CDC had formed part of Steve Webb’s Defined Ambition project, and when this was unceremoniously dumped three years ago, many commentators believed that future discussion of CDC would end too.

However, a key development was the groundbreaking deal made between the Royal Mail and the Communication Workers Union. This saw the establishment of a CDC arrangement as a replacement for a closed Defined Benefit (DB) scheme. Nothing like this had been agreed in the UK before, and primary legislation would be necessary to incorporate key characteristics of CDC into UK pensions law.

Pensions Aspects February 2019
Pensions Aspects February 2019
The key appeal of CDC lies in the extent to which it offers a viable compromise between traditional DC and DB provision.

Firstly, the scheme is deemed to be DC in that the formal benefit promise consists of fixed rates of contribution from the employer and membership. 

However, contributions are allocated not to individual member pots but instead invested in a single fund, as with DB schemes.

Member benefits are provided in the form of scheme pensions rather than through annuitisation or drawdown. Crucially, these benefits are not guaranteed but are based on ‘target’ benefits calculated on a basis which reflects a member’s service and earnings levels as well as their contribution history. Benefits can, if necessary, be scaled back both before and after retirement if there is a funding strain. Research by Aon has suggested that CDC benefits paid to Dutch pensioners are significantly higher than benefits paid in the UK through conventional DC.

Perhaps the single greatest appeal of CDC is that it offers, for the first time, equitable risksharing between the scheme’s sponsor and membership.

Whilst benefits are not guaranteed, the Dutch experience has been that there is reasonable stability, and, in any event, the unpredictable factors associated with traditional DC decumulation are avoided altogether.

CDC is not universally welcomed and has its critics. Many are concerned at the possibility of cross subsidies seeing younger members paying the benefits of pensioners at the expense of their own prospects. Others fear the kind of funding problems which have come to plague DB schemes.

Many also believe it is too late for the private sector as most DB schemes are closed with DC already in place to replace them and perhaps CDC is more suited to the public sector.

We are perhaps at the beginning of a new chapter in the provision of workplace pensions in the UK. However, will CDC appeal to employers? Time will tell.

Download

back to Pensions Aspects Magazine

Last update: 13 July 2020

Tim Middleton
Tim Middleton
Pensions Management Institute
Director of Policy and External Affairs

Pension Trustee Services Manager

Salary: £50000 - £68000 pa

Location: Leeds, West Yorkshire

Employee Benefits Consultant

Salary: £55000 - £75000 pa

Location: London

Senior DC Consultant

Salary: £70000 - £90000 pa

Location: London

You may also like:

From minor data to Master Trusts
09 October 2020

From minor data to Master Trusts

Member engagement in 2030

This is the third essay in a series of six produced by the PMI’s Master Trust Innovation Workstream. This essay aims to set out how we can expect member engagement with Master Trusts to evolve in the next five to ten years

Read more
“Innovation opportunities do not come with the tempest but with the rustling of the breeze” Peter Drucker
09 October 2020

“Innovation opportunities do not come with the tempest but with the rustling of the breeze” Peter Drucker

September 2020 marked the first time the PMI has offered a large scale online exam with its Certificate in Pensions Calculations, traditionally a paper-based exam, moving into the digital world across all of the United Kingdom and Ireland. Approximately 700 learners participated in the series of exams over the month.

Read more