PMI Crest
PMI
Recourse and your journey plan can you get there from here?
9 April 2021

Recourse and your journey plan can you get there from here?

The strength of the covenant will, in part, determine how much risk a scheme can take on its funding journey and, therefore, how long a scheme will take to achieve its long-term funding target. The starting point in evaluating the covenant is understanding where the legal obligation to your pension scheme lies.

Has the recourse changed over time?

Recourse can be simple: most schemes generally start with a single employer being the main UK operating company. However, the passage of time and natural business evolution often impact the covenant and the entities on which a scheme is placing its reliance.

An employer’s economic substance may have reduced via transactions or underinvestment over time, often due to mergers and acquisitions (M&A) or intergroup restructuring. As such, the sponsoring entity may have more limited capacity to support a scheme than it had historically.

Another common issue is that the sponsoring employer is a holding company or a service company, with no underlying cash generating activities. Whilst a holding company may hold equity in other group entities, its cash flow could be dependent on the availability and timing of subsidiary dividends, often out of the control of the sponsoring employer’s directors.

Ultimately, cash flow pays pensions and confidence in the availability and predictability of that cash flow now and in the future underpins how much risk a scheme should be running.

Is the journey plan relying on informal wider group support?

Where employers have been absorbed into larger groups, including overseas parents, such enlarged groups can be significant relative to a scheme’s UK employer. In some instances, we have seen trustees implicitly placing reliance on the wider group (often with the sponsor’s encouragement) when determining the ability of the covenant to support a scheme’s journey plan.

However, it is often the case that a scheme has no legal recourse to the wider group and can only look to its direct sponsoring employer for financial support when push comes to shove. It is important, therefore, that trustees and sponsors recognise that investment risk taken, and the journey plan targeted, are based on, and proportionate to, actual legal recourse.

In many instances, the covenant can be extended and strengthened through a formal guarantee, at limited cash cost to the sponsor. This may help reduce a scheme’s reliance on cash contributions when setting an optimal journey plan.

Get to know your recourse

Identifying recourse and its strengths and limitations can be informed by a covenant practitioner in concert with legal advice. As well as identifying who the employers are, it is also important to know where they sit within a wider group, their financial significance and what other creditors or contingent obligations may compete for the same value.

Recourse can represent a significant pitfall to a scheme’s journey to full funding. We will be looking at recourse and how to enhance it to match a scheme’s long term goals in more detail at Penfida’s PMI Academy training session on 27 April 2021.

Notes/Sources

This article was featured in Pensions Aspects magazine April 2021 edition.

back to Pensions Aspects Magazine

Last update: 7 April 2021

Alex Radhakrishnan
Alex Radhakrishnan
Penfida
Director

Pensions Projects Specialist – Very Flexible working

Salary: £35000 - £45000 pa

Location: Essex or Hampshire – Very flexible working

Pensions Quality Analyst

Salary: £25000 - £40000 pa

Location: Work for Home or Office locations countrywide

Client Relationship Manager

Salary: £30000 - £50000 pa

Location: Bristol / Home based with need to attend Bristol office

You may also like:

Accessing future cash flow to understand the journey plan
15 September 2021

Accessing future cash flow to understand the journey plan

Ultimately, future cash flows of the sponsor pay pension contributions. A largely historical approach to covenant assessment, focused on past performance and the balance sheet, can misjudge the level of covenant support available or even misrepresent the risks that a scheme faces. A forward-looking approach is an essential part of a robust covenant assessment framework.

Read more
Pensions Aspects June 2021
07 June 2021

Pensions Aspects June 2021

Leading the way. Read the latest issue on the flight path to captivating member engagement.

Read more